The Sunflower Essays

The Sunflower Essays The Sunflower Essay The Sunflower Essay the Nazi soldier didn’t deserve forgiveness because of how great the bad in the act that he carried out. If God forgives someone, does it settle everything? Lawrence is claiming that God doesn’t have anything to do with forgiveness and that man controls forgiveness. We control who can be forgiven and who is unforgivable this decides how everything will be settled. Who decides if someone is forgiven, the victim; perpetrator; the Law; God? The victim decides when someone is forgiven. The victim can choose to forgive a perpetrator according to how great the bad act that was carried out on the victim. Should the Nazi officer be forgiven? According to Lawrence, the Nazi officer should not have been forgiven because his wrong doings are so bad that they are un forgivable. Manes Sperber (Austrian-French novelist, essayist, and psychologist) What is forgiveness? According to Manes, forgiveness is what people seek to have a peace of mind after all their wrong doings when they are on the verge of death. In the story â€Å"The Sunflower† the soldier only came to realization of his wrong doings on his death bed and wanted to seek forgiveness from any Jew to have a clear conscience. Who has the right to forgive? The victim has the right to forgive, however the perpetrator will be benefitting more from the forgiveness. Sperber is standing in the logos where he is looking at directly right and wrong and also fair and unfair. It will be unfair for the victim to also give mental peace to the perpetrator after the wrong he did. If God forgives someone, does it settle everything? Sperber is looking at it from a logos perspective where God doesn’t have anything to do with forgiveness. Showing that forgiveness is between man and is a complex issue between man. The victim either can choose to forgive or can choose not to forgive. Who decides if someone is forgiven, the victim; perpetrator; the Law; God? The victim decides if someone is forgiven because the perpetrator seeking forgiveness is a selfish act. Perpetrator only seeks to have peace of mind and the victim can choose to give it to them or not. Should the Nazi officer be forgiven? According to Sperber, the Nazi officer should not be forgiven because he is being selfish and only seeking forgiveness because he is on his death bed. Charles Fowler (Student of Saint Leo University) What is Forgiveness? [ 1 ]. Wiesenthal, S. (1998). The Sunflower: On the Possibilities and Limits of Forgiveness [ 2 ]. Wiesenthal, S. (1998). The Sunflower: On the Possibilities and Limits of Forgiveness [ 3 ]. Wiesenthal, S. (1998). The Sunflower: On the Possibilities and Limits of Forgiveness [ 4 ]. Wiesenthal, S. (1998). The Sunflower: On the Possibilities and Limits of Forgiveness